Was the astrologer actually able to tell the future?

A. Yes, because it was illegal to set up as an astrologer without being able to tell the future.

B. No, because the story said he had a working knowledge of the usual human troubles, and let the other
speak until it was clear what the problem was.

C. Yes, because he saw that Guru Nayak had been stabbed in the past.

D. No, because the story says it's impossible for any human to tell the future.